I often wonder how to describe myself when it comes to religion. I’ve been pretty much everything from an atheist to an Evangelical Christian, with explorations into Buddhism, Satanism, Religious Science (the last group I actually joined), and a few others.
The best that I can come up with to describe myself is that I’m a spiritual atheist.
Atheist
I don’t believe in a single omnipotent, omniscient being who sometimes feels like controlling things and sometimes just leaves them to his rival. There is no objective evidence for either. For a long time I wouldn’t go beyond “agnostic”, which is commonly defined as a person who isn’t sure about the existence of God. Of course, I also can’t be 100% positive that there isn’t a Flying Spaghetti Monster out there, but I’m pretty sure there isn’t.
Spiritual
I remember a handout that I picked up from an outpatient rehab I was in (a couple of times) that had an explanation I could accept (of course, I have no idea where it is now, but I’ll try to remember to post the proper kudos when/if it turns up). The essay said that originally, the word spiritual had nothing to do with God or gods. It’s root word, “spirit”, comes from the Latin for “breath” (spiritus). It has more to do with that which gives life than worship.
That which gives life… that’s what I want!
That which gives life can encompass a whole bunch of things… from the breath I take, to my beating heart, to the neurons firing in my brain. It can be an encouraging word from a friend, a book that I read that changes my life’s direction, or two of my ancestors from a thousand years ago having sex, which resulted in me.
Practicing Spirituality
So what would it mean to practice spirituality, or to live a spiritual way of life?
If I follow the above definition, it would be to live in a way that adds more life, and doesn’t take away from it. It can involve working with the unseen, but it doesn’t have to. I can’t see my breath, but I sure as hell knows when it stops. I never heard my ancestors doing the deed, but they must have, or I wouldn’t be here now.
So even as an atheist, I accept the unseen. I try do those things which others, whether they are Christian, Jewish, Muslim, Satanists, Wiccans, Religious Scientists, or whatever, have said gives them life.
And I discard that which I can’t or won’t accept.
I must admit that too often I throw out the baby with the bathwater. I’ve stop going to AA because of all the Christian-centric God talk. Even when I was a hardcore fundie, I couldn’t find a church because even the most biblically literal of them just didn’t meet my standards of holiness. (Of course, after rejecting them I’d spend hours racking up thousands of dollars in phone sex charges that someone else would have to pay for… but that’s another blog post.)
I’m only now beginning to be comfortable with the fact that I don’t have to “officially” belong to any group, sect, religion, or cult. If my beliefs serve me, I’ll hold onto them. If they don’t, I can always drop them and find new ones that do. I think that’s why Religious Science is still my favorite western organized religion, and Buddhism my favorite from the east. Each is very open, but I still can’t claim them as my own.
Using the Unseen
In The Art of Happiness, the Dalai Lama talks about a discussion he had with scientists on thoughts and brain chemicals. (Once again, I don’t know where the book is, so I’m working from memory here…) It’s a pretty well accepted fact in the scientific community that the chemicals and activity in our brains are what cause our thoughts and emotions. The Dalai Lama asked the question: Isn’t it possible that the thoughts are there first? That they come from somewhere else, and that the thoughts cause the chemical reactions? The scientists he was talking to wouldn’t accept that as a possibility.
The search for spirituality involves a whole lot of “What If” thinking. This can and has allowed charlatans and “false prophets” to rise and become accepted by thousands. But if we lose our “what if”, we would have lost the wheel, the airplane, electric light, E equals MC squared… and a whole lot of great science fiction!
Think of how a person from just a few hundred years ago would react if you showed him a self contained box with the numbers 0-9 on it, along with some other symbols, and told him that this box allowed you to communicate with anyone who had a similar box, as long as you knew the code, the series of numbers to press, that would contact their box.
WITCH! Burn Him!
But now cell phones have become an almost indispensable part of my own culture. How about a horseless carriage? How about a worldwide network of machines that talk to each other? Think about all of the radio waves passing through your body right now; they contain so much information it’s mind boggling.
For me, the practice of spirituality is like the cell phone. It’s trying to find that combination of numbers that will connect me to whatever it is that’s out there that will give me more of the breath of life.
If it’s True, Shouldn’t it Work for Everyone?
One of the things that I find distasteful (and often dangerous) about some religions and groups is their claim on having the one true way. If their program doesn’t make your life better, if you can’t accept some of their beliefs, at best you are ostracized, at worst, killed. It becomes more about the beliefs and maintaining the structure than about the lives of the followers.
I’ve spent a long time looking for that one final answer… and if it is out there, I haven’t found it yet. Some may say that it’s because I haven’t really committed, if it works for them then it should work for me.
Not necessarily.
While two healthy human brains operate within certain parameters and along the same lines, there are enough differences, for any number of reasons, that will cause one person’s thoughts, emotions, perceptions, and beliefs to be different from another’s. Which means that with the same outward form, different results will be achieved.
When I hear the word God, I think one thing, you think something else.
If I may use the cell phone analogy again: my Samsung phone, while operating on the same basic principles, simply does not have the capabilities of your iPhone. Of course, as humans, we can change, we can grow, while a cell phone cannot. But it does no better to criticize a person, even yourself, for not “getting with the program” or “having enough faith” than it does to yell at my Samsung for not being able to play MP3s. It can’t, as it is.
And that’s what’s so cool about being human. We have the power and the ability to change, either on our own or, if necessary, by finding the help out there to teach us how.
If we want to.
11 Comments
No one set of beliefs is going to work for everyone, while the principles that drive that set of beliefs is the same across individuals and cultures. That’s why there are so many different yogas - each is intended for a different personality type.
It’s really good to begin to accept that, Rick. Thanks for putting it simply.
I hope I didn’t put it too simply. I don’t think all belief systems are fully equivalent, nor that they can’t be abused or misinterpreted or oversimplified, nor that some aren’t more effective than others in effecting personal growth and healthy living. But the basic principle behind the universe is one, and we all see that principle and interpret it, creating our personal mythology, from our own unique perspective.
That’s a terrific guiding principle. I’m going to add it to my quotes database if you don’t mind.
I don’t think you oversimplified it, Rick. It figure it can be assumed that the Church of the Flying Spaghetti Monster’s theology may not be as worthwhile to follow as that of one of the Buddhist schools of thought… but then again, that’s one I haven’t tried!
And just to give credit where credit is due, the “adding more life” idea is right out of Wattles’ “The Science of Getting Rich.” But feel free to use it the way I said it.
If I may suggest an analogy that works for me and seems to resonate with a number of others. When my husband and I first got married, we discussed (argued) a lot about whether we should use exit 24 or 25 when traveling on 95 between Westport and Bridgeport. We finally realized that it really doesn’t matter, because from each you arrive at the same destination. So whoever is driving chooses the exit. So too with religion. We are all trying to get to the same place–a meaningful and worthwhile life. The religion or spirituality is the route to that end.
The first person I suggewsted this to responded, “But I take Exit 23.” That’s okay too.
AS LONG AS YOU DO NO HARM (OR AS LITTLE AS POSSIBLE) AND ADD TO LIFE RATHER THAN DESTROYING IT IT REALLY DOESN’T MATTER.
Which is different from saying it doesn’t matter what you believe as long as you believe something. I don’t think the the six million who died in the Holocaust and their familiews or the the families of the people who died on 9-11 could agree.
That is a great analogy, Mom (I think it’s so cool that my mom reads my blog!). And yes, I agree with you that just “believing something” can sometimes be worse than believing nothing.
Hi Betsy.
It is cool that your mom reads your blog, Lyman.
I believe that all of the religions can help us find God but when they start condemning the other religions and saying that they are the only ones with “truth” then the purpose is defeated and they pull themselves farther from God. We are all so different, why would God give us a “one size fits all”? Aren’t we all part of the Universal Energy?
This is a very unpopular stance in the dogmatic place that I live. Many of my neighbors think they have the only true direct line to God. I never could buy into their dogma.
I have written a great deal about this but I keep most of it in my private writings file.
You sound as if you’ve found your way that works for you. That is what is important.
Karen: that is what’s important. Thanks.
I’ve always known I’m a spiritual soul, but I just cannot subscribe to dogmatic religious b.s. On a run yesterday, I put the two together…I am spiritualbody, yet I don’t believe in gods….more specifically, I don’t believe in gods for me. For the needy, take all the gods you want, take all the gods you need, but please quit trying to convince me you have the secret password and secret handshake to heaven. I could give a flying phuck. Leave me be, and my world will be right.
I hear you, BuffNutts. Our relationship with God (the Universe, our Higher Power, whatever you call it) is a deeply personal things. While religion can provide direction to and community for people looking for a connection to the divine, it’s still up to us to find our own path.
Thanks for the comment!
5 Trackbacks
[...] I’m not an atheist, I do appreciate Lyman’s perspective as a spiritual atheist. He believes in the underlying principles that are common to most religions, but not any one [...]
[...] original host and founder of the Personal Development Carnival, Lyman Reed, presents The Spiritual Atheist posted at Creating a Better [...]
[...] The Spiritual Atheist - by - Lyman Reid :: Creating a Better Life [...]
[...] One of the reasons that it jazzes me so much when I see these connections is because I spent so long trying to figure out just who was “right”. When I considered myself a Christian, everything those Muslims said just had to be wrong. If I’m a member of A.A., then don’t even talk to me about SMART Recovery. If I’ve got on my atheist hat, don’t you DARE even try mentioning God to me. (If you care, I still consider myself a “Spiritual Atheist.”) [...]
[...] one and the same, but I guess it took a teacher from a familiar, traditional religion to help this spiritual atheist become comfortable with the G [...]